Skip to content
Methodology · Standard v1.4

Transparency Index methodology

How we score every prop firm on transparency. The same 9 markers and the same rules for every firm, scored only from evidence you can check yourself: the firm's own website, the Internet Archive and UK Companies House.

Standard: v1.4 First published: Last checked: Firms scored: 191

Think a score is wrong? Challenge it with a link to the firm's own website and we will re-check it against the same rules.

Contents
  1. What this index is
  2. Why transparency matters
  3. Sources we use
  4. The 9 markers
  5. Score bands
  6. Evidence & confidence
  7. Star ratings
  8. Why scores fell in October 2026
  9. What we don't measure
  10. Independence
  11. Challenge a score
  12. Updates & versions
01 / Overview

What this index is

We score active prop firms on 9 transparency markers. Each firm gets a single score out of 100. The current scores use evidence standard v1.4 and were checked on 10 October 2026. 191 firms are scored.

This page sets out exactly how the scoring works: the sources, the markers, the points for each marker and the rules we apply. If you think a score is wrong, you can challenge it using the form below.

The scores are free to reuse with credit: download the data (CSV or JSON) and see how to cite the index. What the scores show across all firms: Transparency Index reports.

Why a rulebook instead of opinions?

Because anyone can re-check the work. Every score points to a quote from the firm's own website, so a trader, another reviewer or the firm itself can read the same page, apply the same rules and see whether they reach the same score. When we disagree, the discussion is about the evidence.

02 / Rationale

Why transparency matters

Traders pay evaluation fees to firms they often know little about: who runs them, where they are registered, whether they pay out, and whether the rules they sign up to will still apply later.

Most reviews look at features (account size, profit split, drawdown type) or at success stories. Neither tells you how open a firm is about how it operates.

This index measures something narrower: what a firm discloses about itself on its own website. How clear its prices, refunds and rules are. Whether it names the people and company behind it. Whether it has announced changes that affect existing accounts.

A firm with a high score can still be the wrong firm for you, and a firm with a low score may still pay out. Transparency is one signal, not a verdict on the whole firm.

03 / Sources

Sources we use

Three sources only

  • The firm's own website and help centre. Home, pricing, rules, FAQ, refund policy, terms and conditions, legal and about pages, read with a browser on 10 October 2026. Where a site blocked us on that day, we used copies of its pages that we read on 7–9 October 2026.
  • The Internet Archive (Wayback Machine). The earliest archived copy of the firm's homepage. We use it only to establish how long the site has existed.
  • UK Companies House. Used only to verify a company or person that the firm's own pages name. Companies and registrations in other countries are recorded as "stated, not verified"; we do not look them up.

What we don't use

We do not use Trustpilot, Reddit, YouTube, social media, comparison or review sites, news articles, or unsourced recollection of a firm.

The reasons are simple. Those sources cannot be checked or repeated in the same way. They are open to manipulation by firms, affiliates and rivals. And they measure customer sentiment, not what a firm discloses. If something can only be known from those sources, we treat it as not established and score what the firm's own pages show.

How the scoring runs

Every firm is scored with the same rules. Every score is checked against a verbatim quote from the firm's pages and against the rules on this page.

Only what a firm's pages show counts. A page we could not open does not cost the firm points, and a firm whose site cannot be read at all is not scored.

What we publish per firm

  • The total score out of 100 and the band it falls into
  • The score on each of the 9 markers, with a short reason
  • For every score above 0, a verbatim quote from the firm's page and the page's URL
  • A confidence level, and the date the firm was checked

You can open the evidence for any firm on the index page.

04 / Rubric

The 9 markers

The 9 markers are grouped into 4 categories: payouts and costs 30 points, rules 35, company 20, affiliate disclosure 15. Total: 100 points.

Payouts & costs — 30 pts

Marker 01

Payout proof

10 pts
What it asks
Does the firm publish payout records on its own website? How recent and specific are they?
Why it matters, where we check and how it is scored
Why it matters
Dated payout records on the firm's own site can be checked. Totals and testimonials say much less.
Where we check
The firm's own payout, proof, certificate or transparency pages. Social media posts are not checked.
How it's scored
Within each band, we place a score by how recent and how checkable the records are. Ages are counted to the date we checked the firm.
  • 10: A page or feed on the firm's own site listing individual payouts, each with a date or a "how long ago" label, kept up to date, with the newest within 30 days. Trader names are not required.
  • 9: Recent dated payouts shown as a fixed list, certificate gallery or carousel; or a live list with a problem, such as month-only dates, records the firm calls illustrative, or figures that contradict each other.
  • 8 / 7: Dated records whose newest is 31–60 days old (8) or 61–90 days old (7).
  • 6: Dated records 91–180 days old, or undated payouts that each link to an on-chain transaction.
  • 5: Individual payout amounts without dates (tickers, carousels, certificate images whose dates cannot be read), or dated records over 180 days old shown with totals or claims.
  • 4: Only totals, statistics, claims about the firm's payout record, or testimonials about being paid. A list whose "minutes ago" labels never change, or that shows profits rather than payouts, counts as a claim.
  • 1–3: Only old dated proof, with no totals or claims: 3 if the newest is 6–12 months old, 2 if 1–2 years, 1 if older.
  • 0: Nothing, or only promises and descriptions of how payouts work, such as schedules, "guaranteed payouts" or promised payout times.

Where dates appear only on certificate images, we read them from the images and say so in the firm's evidence.

ScoreWhat earns it
10A live payout dashboard or page on the firm's own site, with dated records from the last 30 days
7–9A page or list of dated, recent payout records or certificates on the firm's own site
4–6Only payout totals, payout claims or testimonials on the firm's own site
1–3Only old payout proof
0No payout proof on the pages we read
Marker 02

Pricing clarity

10 pts
What it asks
Is the full cost of an account clear upfront: evaluation price, resets, monthly fees, activation fees, withdrawal or payout fees, data fees?
Why it matters, where we check and how it is scored
Why it matters
Extra fees add up. You should be able to see the full cost before you pay.
Where we check
Pricing page, FAQ, terms and conditions, refund policy. A deferred activation fee shown next to the price counts as disclosed.
ScoreWhat earns it
10All costs (evaluation, reset, monthly, activation, withdrawal, data) on one page with no ambiguity
7–9Main cost clear; smaller fees disclosed but only in the terms and conditions
4–6Main cost clear but several additional fees hard to find
1–3Several extra charges not shown before purchase
0Misleading pricing, or costs not disclosed at all
Marker 03

Refund policy clarity

10 pts
What it asks
Are refund and cancellation terms written down, easy to find and clear?
Why it matters, where we check and how it is scored
Why it matters
You should know before you pay whether you can get your money back. This marker measures clarity, not generosity: a clearly stated "no refunds" policy on a dedicated page still scores 7–10.
Where we check
Refund policy page, terms and conditions, FAQ. If the firm's pages make conflicting refund statements, the score is capped at 5.
ScoreWhat earns it
10Dedicated refund policy page, clear conditions, stated processing time
7–9Refund terms in the terms and conditions, easy to find, generally clear
4–6Mentioned briefly, conditions vague; conflicting statements across pages (max 5)
1–3Only a passing mention in an FAQ or elsewhere; conditions unclear
0No refund policy on the pages we read

Rules — 35 pts

Marker 04

Rule clarity

10 pts
What it asks
Are the trading rules complete, unambiguous and given as specific numbers?
Why it matters, where we check and how it is scored
Why it matters
Vague rules let a firm fail an account on a judgement call. We count wording such as "at our discretion", "excessive risk", "abusive" or "gambling" that can fail an account without a number behind it.
Where we check
Rules page, terms and conditions, FAQ, evaluation overview.
ScoreWhat earns it
10All rules in one place, given as specific numbers (e.g. "max 2% daily loss = $200 on a $10K account"), no judgement-call wording
7–9All rules listed, mostly specific, only minor ambiguities
4–6Some judgement-call wording ("excessive risk", "abusive trading", "at our discretion")
1–3Rules spread across several pages, frequent ambiguity
0Rules not clearly stated anywhere you can read before buying
Marker 05

Rule stability & track record

15 pts
What it asks
How long has the firm been operating, and has it announced changes that affect existing accounts in the past 12 months?
Why it matters, where we check and how it is scored
Why it matters
Changing the rules on existing customers is a serious trust failure. A longer operating history is some evidence of stability.
Where we check
Operating history starts at the later of the earliest Wayback Machine copy of the firm's homepage and the founding or registration date the firm states (domains are often reused, so an archive copy from before the firm existed does not count). Changes are taken only from announcements on the firm's own pages.
How it's scored
Base score, to 10 October 2026: 12 for 3 years or more; 10 for 1–3 years; 6 for under 1 year or no data. We then deduct for changes the firm announced in the past 12 months that affect existing accounts, or sales pauses: 2 points per change made with notice, down to 1–4 if there were several or no notice, and 0 if a page shows a retroactive disqualification. Changes that apply only to new purchases, and undated changes, are not deducted.
ScoreWhat earns it
13–15Not awarded under standard v1.4. It needs a verified 12-month record of no rule changes, which we cannot yet establish from the sources we use. Until it is awarded, the highest possible total is 97; Excellent (80 or more) is still reachable.
123 or more years of operating history, no deductible changes
101–3 years of operating history, no deductible changes
5–8Under 1 year or no data (6), or a longer history less 2 points per announced change with notice
1–4Several changes affecting existing accounts, or changes without notice, in the past 12 months
0A page shows a change that retroactively disqualified customers
Marker 06

Hidden-rule disclosure

10 pts
What it asks
Are the rules that commonly catch traders out (consistency, scaling, weekend and overnight holding, news trading, EA and bot use, maximum lot or contract size) stated before you pay?
Why it matters, where we check and how it is scored
Why it matters
These are the rules most likely to fail an account unexpectedly. Stating them on the rules, pricing or FAQ pages means you know what you are signing up for. Rules that appear only in the terms and conditions score lower.
Where we check
Rules page, pricing page, FAQ, full terms and conditions.
ScoreWhat earns it
10All restrictive rules clearly stated on the rules or pricing page
7–9Most stated clearly, 1–2 only in fine print or the FAQ
4–6Some stated before purchase, others only in the terms and conditions
1–3Several restrictive rules not stated before purchase
0Major restrictive rules not stated anywhere before purchase

Company — 20 pts

Marker 07

Ownership disclosure

10 pts
What it asks
Does the firm name its owners or founders and its company on its own pages, and can we verify them?
Why it matters, where we check and how it is scored
Why it matters
Named people and companies are accountable. Anonymous ones are not.
Where we check
About and team pages, footer, legal pages. Names are verified on UK Companies House where the firm names a UK company. LinkedIn is not checked.
ScoreWhat earns it
8–10Owners or founders named on the firm's pages and verified on UK Companies House (officer name matches); 10 only with a team listed
4–6Owners or founders named, but not verifiable from our sources (for example, a non-UK company: "stated, not verified")
1–3Company named but no people (3); a generic team page with no names (1–3)
0No team or ownership information on the pages we read
Marker 08

Regulatory clarity

10 pts
What it asks
What legal entity is behind the firm, where is it registered, and does the firm say clearly whether it is regulated or offers simulated trading?
Why it matters, where we check and how it is scored
Why it matters
Knowing what kind of business you are dealing with tells you what you can do if something goes wrong. Simulated-trading firms and regulated brokers have different obligations; both can be legitimate. The failure is not saying which one you are.
Where we check
The firm's own legal pages: terms and conditions, privacy policy, imprint, footer. We do not judge whether a claimed licence is real. A regulation claim stated as fact without specifics we can verify is capped at 6.
ScoreWhat earns it
10Entity name, registration number, jurisdiction and regulatory status stated, plus an explicit "simulated trading / not a broker" statement where it applies
7–9Legal entity and jurisdiction stated, regulatory status implicit
4–6Partial disclosure or ambiguity about what kind of entity this is; unverifiable regulation claims (max 6)
1–3Generic location claims without any company detail
0No legal entity or jurisdiction on the pages we read

Affiliate disclosure — 15 pts

Marker 09

Affiliate disclosure

15 pts
What it asks
If the firm runs an affiliate, partner or IB programme, does it document it and require affiliates to disclose the relationship?
Why it matters, where we check and how it is scored
Why it matters
Much of what traders read about prop firms is written by affiliates paid per sign-up. A firm that requires its affiliates to disclose that payment makes it easier for you to tell recommendation from advertising.
Where we check
The firm's affiliate or partner programme pages, its terms and conditions, and site footer.
ScoreWhat earns it
13–15Affiliate programme documented on the firm's own pages, and those pages or its terms require affiliates to disclose the relationship
10No affiliate programme found on the pages we read ("none found on the firm's pages")
7–10Programme page exists, but disclosure wording is vague or absent
4–6Programme only hinted at (a sign-up link, no terms)
05 / Bands

Score bands

We group total scores (0–100) into 4 bands for quick comparison. The number itself is what matters; the bands are there to help you read the table at a glance.

80–100
Excellent
60–79
Good
40–59
Mixed
0–39
Poor

At the latest check (scores checked from 10 October 2026), 76 firms are in the Good band, 113 firms are in the Mixed band and 1 firm is in the Poor band.

06 / Evidence

Evidence & confidence

Every score points to a source

Every marker score above 0 links to a verbatim quote of 300 characters or fewer from the firm's own page, with the page's URL. Where a score rests on something we could not find, it is labelled "not found on the pages we read". You can open the evidence for any firm on the index page.

Confidence levels

  • High: every marker rests on direct evidence from the firm's pages. 110 firms.
  • Medium: 1–2 markers were scored from absence ("not found on the pages we read"). 76 firms.
  • Low, shown as "provisional": 3 or more markers were scored from absence, or the firm's site was mostly unreadable. 5 firms.

Firms whose website could not be read at all are not scored. At the 10 October 2026 check, that is 8 firms; they are listed on the index page.

07 / Ratings

Star ratings

A firm's MyPropGenius star rating comes directly from its index score: score ÷ 20, rounded down to one decimal. For example, 71/100 becomes 3.5/5. Rounding down keeps the star ratings in line with the bands: 4.0 and above is Excellent, 3.0–3.9 Good, 2.0–2.9 Mixed, below 2.0 Poor.

Ratings that come from a low-confidence score are labelled provisional. Our "Most Trusted" list includes only firms in the Good band or above (a rating of 3.0 or more) whose score is not provisional.

08 / Changes

Why scores fell in October 2026

The scores published up to v1.3 (80 firms, scored in June 2026) relied partly on judgement that was not recorded, and on sources we no longer use. For October 2026 we re-scored every active firm from recorded evidence only, under the rules on this page.

For the 77 firms scored under both v1.3 and v1.4, scores are about 12 points lower on average. No firm currently scores 80 or more.

09 / Limits

What we don't measure

Saying what we don't measure is as important as saying what we do. This index doesn't score firms on:

  • Whether the firm actually pays. We score whether it publishes payout proof on its own site. Whether real customers got paid when they should have is covered separately in our firm reviews.
  • Customer sentiment. Reviews, complaints and social media reflect how customers feel, which is a different question from what a firm discloses.
  • Customer support quality. Response times, helpfulness, how disputes are handled. We look at these case by case in our reviews, not by formula.
  • How many traders pass. What percentage pass evaluations or reach payout. Some firms publish this; most don't. It is not scored.
  • Whether a claimed licence is genuine. We record what the firm states about regulation; we do not judge whether a licence is real.
  • Past complaints, lawsuits or regulatory action. Not scored here, because they come from sources outside the firm's own pages.
  • Trading platform quality. Broker partners, charting tools, execution speed, slippage. Important, but not about transparency.
  • Whether the firm fits your trading style. A rule set that suits a scalper can be wrong for a swing trader. That's a question of fit, not transparency.
One important caveat

A high transparency score doesn't mean you'll do well at that firm. A low score doesn't mean you'll do badly. Use this index alongside our firm reviews and your own checks.

10 / Independence

Independence

We have affiliate links with some of the firms in this index. The same rules, sources and evidence requirements apply to those firms as to every other firm, and every score can be checked against the quotes we publish.

11 / Corrections

Challenge a score

Firms and traders can challenge any score. Send us a link to a page on the firm's own website that changes it, and we will re-check the score against the same rules on this page. When a score changes, the evidence for that firm on the index page shows the new score, the page it rests on and the date we checked.

When to challenge

  • A page on the firm's own website shows something we missed or got wrong
  • The firm has published new information on its own website since we checked
  • The rules on this page were applied incorrectly to the evidence we quoted

We can only use evidence from the three sources above. Links to review sites, social media or news cannot change a score.

Submit a challenge

Fill in the form below. We'll reply to the email you provide. If you work for the firm being scored, please say so in the form; we publish that detail alongside our response.

Paste a link to the page on the firm's own website, and quote the wording that changes the score.

12 / Cadence

Updates & versions

Re-scoring

We aim to re-score every scored firm four times a year (January, April, July, October). The last full re-score was checked on 10 October 2026. Individual scores can be updated sooner when something changes, such as a rule update, an ownership change or a successful challenge.

Version history

Each change to the rules or to the list of firms gets a new version number and a dated entry here, newest first.

  • v1.4.1 — 2026-11-10 — Payout proof: published how a score is placed within each band (see Marker 01, "How it's scored"). Every active firm's payout proof was re-checked against it for consistency; 59 scores changed, each recorded in the change log with its evidence. Bands, point values and evidence standard v1.4 are unchanged.
  • v1.4 — 2026-10-10 — Evidence standard v1.4. Every active firm re-scored from recorded evidence only: the firm's own website and help centre, the earliest Wayback Machine copy of its homepage (for operating history only) and UK Companies House (to verify named companies and people only). Trustpilot, Reddit, YouTube, social media, review sites and news are no longer used. Per-marker rules published on this page, including the operating-history base scores for Rule Stability & Track Record and the decision not to award its 13–15 band yet. Every score above 0 linked to a verbatim quote and URL. 170 firms scored; 8 not scored because their sites could not be read. On 11 October 2026 the firms added that day were scored under the same standard, bringing the index to 192 firms. Scores about 12 points lower on average; no firm currently Excellent.
  • v1.3 — 2026-10-09 — Removed 2 firms that are closed (Swift Funding, ATFunded); 80 firms in scope. No scores changed. Leveled Up Society, also confirmed closed on 9 Oct 2026, was not in the index.
  • v1.2 — 2026-10-08 — Removed 3 firms that are closed or not prop firms (Bespoke Funding, True Trading Group, Pacific Funding); 82 firms in scope. No scores changed.
  • v1.1 — 2026-10-07 — Removed 4 firms that are closed or inactive (SeacrestFunded, FundingTicks, ForFX, The Forex Funder); 85 firms in scope. No scores changed. From this version, every MyPropGenius rating on the site is the firm's Transparency Index score divided by 20, rounded down (e.g. 83/100 = 4.1/5, 80/100 = 4.0/5); firms without a score are shown as "Not yet rated", and ratings from low-confidence or flagged scores are labelled provisional. E8 Funding and E8 Markets merged into one entry (e8funding.com redirects to e8markets.com).
  • v1.0 — 2026-06-07 — First publication. 9 markers, 89 firms in scope (V2 rubric — operating-history signal merged into Rule Stability & Track Record), quarterly update cadence committed.

See the scores

191 prop firms scored against this methodology, with the evidence behind every score.

Open the Transparency Index →